May 27, the police will watch the return of stolen owner
early morning on March 26 this year, Henan, Jilin Street, near a large table row burglaries occurred, two suspects escaped monitoring facilities, stole more than an hour with 445 kinds of watches, the total value of more than 380 million.
Jilin police work lasted 40 Yu Tiancheng cracked this case and was held the morning of May 27 will return stolen goods. Said the owner was grateful for the public security organs donated a vehicle and 3 million in cash.
news playback
Watch uncovered the theft, the owner to a car and 3 yuan to express their gratitude to the public security organs. However, the public security organs have the right to charge the owner of the gift it? Li Jilin people call the newspaper,
tory burch flip flop, said the public security responsibilities detection, this fee should not be grateful to receive, otherwise it will affect the image and prestige, to some extent, but also the injustice of criminal suspects. Expand this reporter interviewed, found considerable controversy.
■ parties say
owner:
willing to table thanks
It is understood that after the incident, the police on the city's hotels, Bath,
tory burch totes, Internet cafes and other places to conduct a comprehensive visit to find people acting suspiciously, and went to Changchun, Shenyang, Harbin, more than 10 cities, visiting more than 40 pawn shops, more than 300 people visited the survey, and finally arrested the suspect at large.
table row in the interview, the owner said that although the public order crime detection since the beginning of things, but the hard work really paid, he presented the police property, is an expression of gratitude is also willing.
Police:
Quanguo owner do not have to donate
yesterday afternoon, the reporter linked to the Jilin Branch of Public Security Secretary Guo Shuming boat operators. He said: p> Subsequently, the reporter went to the Jilin Branch of the Public Security Bureau shipping business, and Yang Xue-Zhi, deputy director for the communication.
Reporter: May 27 of the stolen goods back to the General Assembly,
tory burch sales, the owner donated a car and 30,000 yuan of money, right?
Yang Xue Zhi: ah.
Reporter: cars and money to use somewhere?
Yang Xue-Zhi: the owner has repeatedly stressed, money and cars have to give the vice squad. He is to encourage the public security organs especially the vice squad, in the future more quickly solve the case. Public money used for detection, and not fall to police individual head.
Reporter: he offered to give money is it?
Yang Xue-Zhi: He is an active, voluntary donations, as moved by the expression of gratitude. He insisted the two vehicles began to donate, we were advised him, are hard-earned money, is not easy. After repeated consultations, before agreeing only to a car. Return stolen goods, including the General Assembly ceremony, are asked to engage the owner.
Reporter: Police internal regulations, there are no relevant provisions for acceptance of gifts?
Yang Xue-Zhi: No relevant provisions are, in fact do so. Public security organs do have state financial support, but many specific tasks, such as the valuation of these watches, you need more than 10 million of money. Who out of money? We do not have the money.
Reporter: Is there rejected the provisions of gifts?
Yang Xue-Zhi: reject gift is personal, individual victims of the masses can not accept gifts, but there is no clearly defined public security organs.
Reporter: But there are legal provisions, the executive shall not be used as the recipient object.
Yang Xue-Zhi: have this requirement. But this is a personal gift wishes, not who forced him. We always work overtime weekends, holidays never rest, under the law is how ah? People who do not need help ah? Public security organs also need help.
■ Expert opinion
Professor: You should not accept gifts
interview with Professor Ren Xirong Jilin University School of Law, she said that victims of public security organs should not accept gifts The reasons are five points:
one, and to law.
Second, do not meet the spirit of building a service-oriented government. Government services to the people but their basic duties, in any case neither be too hard.
Third, in the spirit of modern people do not match. Ji Song solve the case the public security organs to East West, is the embodiment of the ancient concept of clean government, rather than the modern spirit of equality and freedom of the people.
its four, easy to develop a breeding ground for corruption of power. Investigators funded by the public security organs of the state treasury expenditure of funds and handling the change in the environment should be central and local government efforts to resolve not to accept gifts for this reason.
Fifth, if the parties have to give, to exhort, and guide it will be donated to welfare institutions or other property of public funds, and not one to accept.
of Criminal Law of China Law Society, vice president of Jilin University PhD supervisor Professor Li Jie also believes that the parties to accept donations as the public security organ, easily lead to social challenge.
Li Jie said the gift was afterwards, if there is no prior agreement, do not constitute bribery, but there is the possibility of contributing to unhealthy practices. If there is handling public security organs in the case of funds, forced to accept the gift has some, but to maintain the fairness of administrative law enforcement, law enforcement should remain neutral and accept the party's gift will destroy that neutrality, at least in public view such suspicion.
lawyers: This conduct alleged illegal
Liu Haibo Ji Lin Gongcheng law firm, said the alleged illegal behavior. According to the provisions of
Liu Haibo said that all administrative acts of the executive must comply with laws, regulations and rules, this is the basic principle of administration according to law. Accordingly, the public security authorities to accept the behavior of the parties is illegal gifts.
■ public debate
supporters: If you find unacceptable, completely emotionally feel, solve the case, the public security organs should be done, but the gift is also the owner of the rights of other things, as long as voluntary, nothing can be questioned.
owner of a business clothing business,
tory burch flip flops, said theft of molecules too hateful, and public security personnel detection difficult, and sometimes have camped. In addition to higher awards, as what the owner said, is also reasonable.
User justice: law enforcement departments can not rely on the improvement of conditions for social donations, but donors should not be refused. The law does not grant the object of the points.
User asingun: Public Security Bureau as a government department, not a bad idea to accept donations, but donations shall be vested in the state.
users Yang Yang: You can close the case meet the
opponents: people feel to spend money to solve the case
public Wang believes that is the duty of the police solve the case, should not accept gifts. Although the expression of gratitude to the owner, is what makes sense, but the feeling of the public security organ donations to donors, some strange, taxpayers several thousand dollars a year tax, that is, to government departments to use. Financial costs allocated by the state, individuals should not cost taxpayers money in disguise.
Northwestern Law faculty, said Zhang Xi, one may say, as long as not expressly prohibited by law, any person or community organizations can voluntarily donated or the recipient. However, the operation of public power should follow a basic principle: that Therefore, government should act in strict accordance with the law, if no corresponding authorization, did is illegal.
■ News Links
■ 2003 年 11 月 11 morning, Yulin refinery workers banners, will thank you letters, pennants and 50 million check to the Yulin City Public Security Bureau,
tory burch wedges, in order to thank the police have detected a very big contract, fraud, money for the plant to recover 2.88 million yuan.
■ 2006 年 9 26, a police helicopter flight airport in Shanxi five places. In the test site, Shanxi Province Public Security Bureau director of a coal mine in particular expressed his gratitude, because the purchase of the helicopter, sponsored by miners 800 million. There are comments that in this incident, the police suspected of collective corruption in Shanxi.
reporter Shi Zhou / map
Linear Mode
